Washington's criminal justice system under the SRA.

In Washington’s criminal justice system, the impact of out-of-state convictions on sentencing under the Sentencing Reform Act (SRA) is a matter of significant importance. Understanding how these convictions are assessed and their implications is essential for both defendants and legal practitioners.

Under the SRA, a defendant’s criminal history is a critical factor in determining the severity of their sentence. This includes convictions obtained outside of Washington state. However, for an out-of-state conviction to affect a defendant’s sentence in Washington, it must be deemed “comparable” to an in-state conviction.

SRA looks at a number of factors including but not limited to:

  • Criminal History
  • Nature and Severity of the Current Offense
  • Offender Characteristics
  • Community Safety
  • Sentencing Guidelines
  • Rehabilitation and Treatment
  • Victim Impact

Top of Form

Bottom of Form

Legal similarity between the out-of-state offense and a comparable Washington offense is the first consideration. This involves a straightforward analysis of whether the elements of the crime in the foreign jurisdiction align with those in Washington. If the legal elements differ substantially, the out-of-state conviction may not be considered comparable.

Factual equivalence is the second aspect to be examined. This requires a deeper dive into the specific circumstances of the out-of-state conviction to determine if the conduct would have constituted a comparable offense in Washington. The court relies on evidence that has been proven beyond a reasonable doubt or admitted by the defendant to assess factual equivalence.

Recent legal interpretations highlight the importance of rigorous scrutiny in evaluating out-of-state convictions.

Mere allegations or charges are insufficient to justify their inclusion in a defendant’s criminal history. The state must meet a high standard of proof to demonstrate that the out-of-state conviction is truly comparable to a Washington offense.

For defendants facing the potential impact of out-of-state convictions on their sentencing, understanding their rights and legal options is paramount. Diligent defense representation is crucial in challenging questionable interpretations of out-of-state convictions and advocating for fair treatment under Washington’s legal framework.

At the Law Office of Erin Bradley McAleer, we are dedicated to protecting the rights of our clients and ensuring they receive just treatment under the law. If you or a loved one are navigating the complexities of out-of-state convictions in a Washington criminal case, our experienced legal team is here to provide guidance and support every step of the way. Call us today at (360) 334-6277 to schedule an appointment today!